Saturday, February 8, 2014

Comparative Religion 202 –Samuel Lasco----Tests 1

Definitions
  1. The Mysterium Tremendum et Fascinans
Human beings regard anything sacred or holy with ambivalent feeling: fear struggles with attractions. Like a child before a huge bonfire the believer trembles with mingled dread and fascination. Rudolph Otto used this image in his famous study The Idea of the Holy, distinguishing “the holy” from moral perfection or intellectual respect, calling it “the numinous.” He characterized it as mysterium tremendum et fascinans.
  1. Shamanism
A mode of dealing with the spirit world through the agency of an individual set apart as spirit possessed and specially equipped to deal with superhuman forces. (The term shaman is generically applied to healers, exorcists, sorcerers, magicians, fetish priests, and the like.
  1. The Rig Veda
(Literally, “the Veda of stanzas of praise”) is an anthology of religious poetry in ten books, containing over one thousand hymns and reflecting the religious devotion of long- established family and other groups before and during the Vedic Age. At first these hymns (some by individuals) existed only in oral form. They are prayers addressed to a single or often to two or more deities called devas or “shining ones,” a word identical with the Latin deus (whence also comes, of course, the English word deity), whose residences were found in three religions—the earth, the heavens, and the intermediate air.
  1. The: Trimurti: Define the characteristics of each god. 
At the pinnacle of the framework, the Brahmins advanced the concept of the Trimurti or The Triad of Gods; Brahma, Vishnu, and Shiva.

Brahma is the creator of the universe, and the source from which all the individual deities have sprung, and into which all will ultimately be absorbed. "As milk changes to curd, and water to ice, so is Brahma variously transformed and diversified, without aid of exterior means of any sort. The human soul, according to the Vedas, is a portion of the supreme ruler, as a spark is of the fire. "BRAHMA, at first a word meaning prayer and devotion, becomes in the laws of Manu the primal God, first-born of the creation, from the self-existent being, in the form of a golden egg. He became the creator of all things by the power of prayer. In the struggle for ascendancy, which took place between the priests and the warriors, Brahma naturally became the deity of the former. But, meantime, as we have seen, the worship or Vishnu had been extending itself in one region and that of Siva in another. Then took place those mysterious wars between the kings of the Solar and Lunar races, of which the great epics contain all that we know. And at the close of these wars a compromise was apparently accepted, by which Brahma, Vishnu, and Siva were united in one supreme God, as creator, preserver, and destroyer, all in one.
            Vishnu occupies the second place in the triad of the Hindus, and is the personification of the preserving principle. To protect the world in various epochs of danger, Vishnu descended to the earth in different incarnations, or bodily forms, which descents are called Avatars. They are very numerous, but ten are more particularly specified. The first Avatar was as Matsya, the Fish, under which form Vishnu preserved Manu, the ancestor of the human race, during a universal deluge. The second Avatar was in the form of a Tortoise, which form he assumed to support the earth when the gods were churning the sea for the beverage of immortality, Amrita. We may omit the other Avatars, which were of the same general character, that is, interpositions to protect the right or to punish wrong-doers, and come to the ninth, which is the most celebrated of the Avatars of Vishnu, in which he appeared in the human form of Krishna, an invincible warrior, who by his exploits relieved the earth from the tyrants who oppressed it. Buddha is by the followers of the Brahmanical religion regarded as a delusive incarnation of Vishnu, assumed by him in order to induce the Asuras, opponents of the gods, to abandon the sacred ordinances of the Vedas, by which means they lost their strength and supremacy. Kalki is the name of the TENTH Avatar, in which Vishnu will appear at the end of the present age of the world to destroy all vice and wickedness, and to restore mankind to virtue and purity.
            Siva is the third person of the Hindu triad. He is the personification of the destroying principle. Though the third named, he is, in respect to the number of his worshippers and the extension of his worship, before either of the others. In the Puranas (the scriptures of the modern Hindu religion) no allusion is made to the original power of this god as a destroyer; as that power is not to be called into exercise till after the expiration of twelve millions of years, or when the universe will come to an end; and Mahadeva (another name for Siva) is rather the representative of regeneration than of destruction. The worshippers of Vishnu and Siva form two sects, each of which proclaims the superiority of its favorite deity, denying the claims of the other, and Brahma, the creator, having finished his work, seems to be regarded as no longer active, and has now only one temple in India, while Mahadeva and Vishnu have many. The worshippers of Vishnu are generally distinguished by a greater tenderness for life and consequent abstinence from animal food, and worship less cruel than that of the followers of Siva.

Comparisons
  1. Tribal Religions and World Foundation Religions, including the four major paradigms.
WORLDWIDE POPULATION IN PRIMAL CULTURES: ca. 94 million
SACRED TRADITION: Oral, pictorial, or transmitted through artifacts
CASE STUDIES: Primal cultures of the recent past:
The Dieri of Australia Date of study, ca. 1865 Population, ca. 10,000
The BaVenda of South Africa Date of study, ca. 1920 Population, ca. 150,000
The Cherokees of Southeastern United States Date of study, ca. 1825 Population, ca. 18,000

None of us can hope to see the world through the eyes of our prehistoric ancestors. We pore over their cave paintings, their implements, the disposition of bodies and artifacts in their burial sites, and we make conjectures. We do, however, have a clearer view of primal religions in our own time. (The term primal is here used to refer to religions in an original state, that is, confined to a relatively small cultural setting, isolated, not branching from other religions, and “not exported.”) Although there is no clear warrant for interpreting the probable intentions of prehistoric people by analogy to those of more recent primal cultures, we find ourselves taking note of parallels simply because there are no alternative models to inform our suppositions. We should view the analogies with caution. Conjectures about prehistoric cultures and observations of isolated primal cultures in the recent past converge on one vital function of religion: the linking of the visible, everyday world with powerful unseen forces and spirits. In this regard, the lives of ancient peoples were far more intimately interwoven with the forces of nature than moderns can readily conceptualize. It is our habit to objectify: the sudden storm is a product of colliding air masses; an eclipse is a product of planetary orbits; the deceased grandfather in a dream is a product of brain function. In ancient or primal cultures the storm, the eclipse, and the dream appear not as objects but as “others” in a subject-to-subject mode. In a profound sense this meant an enlargement of the scope of religious encounter. To understand such a worldview puts special demands upon our powers of empathy. The history of Islam has often been linked to the existence of an Islamic state or empire. From its beginnings, Islam existed and spread as a community-state; it was both a faith and a political order. Within centuries after his death, Muhammad's local Arabian polity became a vast empire, extending from North Africa to Southeast Asia. The development of Islam and state institutions (the caliphate, law, education, the military, social services) were intertwined. Again, the Prophetic period provided the paradigm for later generations. For it was in Medina that the Quranic mandate took on form and substance under the guidance and direcions, Ancestral Venerattion of the Prophet. The Medinan community formed a total framework for state, society, and culture. It epitomized the Quranic mandate for Muslims as individuals and as a community umma to transform the world itself through action in the world. This aspiration and ideal has constituted the challenge for the Islamic community throughout much of its history. It inspired Muhammad to transform a local shiekdom into a transtribal state. Paradigmatic Metanarratives: nature, harmony, liberation, history. Order of existence: cognitive/intellectual, aesthetics/emotions, moral/ethical, and logos, the natural order of universe.

  1.  Soul Concepts, Ancestral Veneration, and Animism
There is no single history which covers the various tribal religions. Many seem to have developed according to happenings in nature and fear of certain events (lightning, thundering’s, earthquake’s for example) which were not understood. Normal happenings in life: birth, adulthood, marriage, death--gave reason for rejoicing or sorrowing. This caused the followers to look to a higher power. These tribal religions are usually found in more underdeveloped areas of the world.  Some Common Features:
Animisrn: Nature and the world around is alive with spirits and mystical forces (personal or impersonal), thus things’ are worshipped and venerated.
Magic: Attempting to force nature to one's will. Sympathetic Magic attempts to coerce nature to behave in a certain manner by performing that act oneself on a smaller scale (example: voodoo dolls) Fetish--an object that controls nature in fashion (example: lucky rabbits feet)
Divination: Seeing into the future, usually through the use of a Shaman.
Taboo: Certain actions and objects must be avoided so as not to anger the spirit world.
Totems: Some primitive religions express the kinship they feel with nature, for example, identifying themselves with a particular animal.
Sacrifice: One of the most common practices of all religions. It is variously considered in terms of feeding the spirits, giving a gift to the spirits, or establishing a bond between men and the spirits.
Rites of Passage: Certain rituals are carried out at key points in the life of a person.
Worship of Ancestors: Believing that the soul lives on after the death of the body, led to efforts to avert the evil the dead might do. Ancestors are worshipped to also please the dead so they will benefit the living.
Evil is caused by human mistakes, chance and malicious sorcery.
 Goal is to fulfill one's particular destiny now (a tribal position, attaining old age, dying of natural causes, bearing children). Salvation or the futures are not considered much.
For spiritual help tribal members go to the diviners or seek help from ancestor spirits. Belief that man and God became estranged when a greedy man tried to take too much food; Also, a belief that man was cursed by a lizard-like creature.
Worship consists of family rites, personal prayers, use of religious objects, and offerings made to a deity. Transmigration of Souls--you move from caste to caste in various lives. The ultimate goal is to learn to deny the world and thus achieve release or moksha.
Circumcision is practiced in some tribes of New Guinea.
Shamans or holy men help reveal the will of God to the laity.
With some tribes, possession by a spirit of the deity is desirable.

  1. Hymn of Creation(page 79) re; status of the gods
The gods of the Aryans were not like the animals figures of the Harappa’s, but transcendent sky gods who actively helped them fight against their enemies. These included both indigenous peoples and earlier immigrants to the area. The Vedic hymns were the verses recited, for the most part, at sacrifices to Aryan gods, which they called devas. Devas represented and controlled the forces of nature, they were divine power. However, the powers which attracted the attention of the Aryans, when they came to South Asia, were the cosmic in nature--the sky, the sun, the order of nature itself. Their two most important sky gods were Varuna and Indra. Varuna was the guardian of the cosmic order; he created the world and ruled it by the standard of rita--the proper course of things. Rita provided a structure for the other celestial powers. Indra was the thunder god, famous for successful warfare and special champion of the Aryan warrior.

These two gods were two sides of a divine rule--the active side (Indra) and the passive side (Varuna). They represented active intervention to overcome obstacles and bestow bounty on men, and the eternal universal order. Varuna was to recede in importance, as the Aryans fought to secure a foothold in the northwest plains. The warrior Indra became the greatest of the devas. At the sacrifices where Rig Veda hymns were recited, the devas were invited to come and sit around the sacrificial fire, to receive the hospitality of the Aryans who sacrificed animals in their honor. The priests of the Aryans attempted to incur the goodwill of the devas by singing them songs of praise. The composition of these hymns became confined to a small number of poet priests who were considered inspired. Because the Vedas were sacred and essential to the well-being of the Aryans, their priests developed special techniques to aid them in remembering the words to the hymns accurately and in teaching them to younger generations of priests. Most of what we know about the Aryans comes from these hymns.

  1. Karma and Samsara re. reincarnation and caste
No precise founding, but grew up largely between 1500 B.C. and 400 B.c.  Brahman: "World Soul" is a three-in-one god or Trimurti.
l. Brahma: Creator who is largely ignored in worship.
2. Vishnu: Preserver who is actively worshipped particularly as rishna.
3. Shiva: Destroyer who is both worshipped and feared.
Millions or lesser gods or spirits are also reverenced. THE VEDAS--Hymns and rituals of priests which are the fundamental scriptures. The RIG \/EDA is the oldest and most important of the Vedas.
The UPANISHADS are commentaries on the Vedas.
The BHAGAVAD GITA is an epic poem which influential document in the religious history of India.
Lord's Song."
Aryans (meaning "Noble Ones") led by rajahs or chieftains were nomads who invaded India from Persia between 1700-1500 B.C. They were Indo-European and brought the worship of multiple gods with them. Their beliefs became mixed with the native Indian traditions to form what we now know as Hinduism. The Hindu faith endured many difficult and trying periods. From 500 B.C. to 500 A.D. internal difficulties both politically and economically caused the religion to fit more the character of the Indian people. Then, the Hindus had to endure 750 years of subjection to the Muslims (999-1757 A.D.). Christianity tried to leave its mark on India, but did not succeed when the Europeans (mainly the British) dominated India from 1757-1947. One of the most famous modern Hindus was Mahatma Gandhi (1869-1948) who through his pacifism and fasting led the Indians to independence. Hinduism remains the dominant religion of India.
Karma--the force that binds the soul to an endless cycle of death and rebirth unless it is broken; good from good, evil from evil law of cause and effect.
  • Moksha--release, to become at one with the universal spirit.
  • No Founder and No Fixed Creed.
  • Hindu Religious Practice--is very personal.
  • Two Common Beliefs of All Hindus:
    • Validity of the Vedas--as the inspired Word
    • Caste system--all people are born into one of four levels or castes.
·         Caste System:
o   Brahrnin--holy men
o   Kshatriya--rulers and warriors
o   Vaishyas- -merchantsa nd craf tsmen
o   Sudras- -comm oners
Each caste has its own specialized duties (Dharma).
Transmigration of Souls--you move from caste to caste in various lives. The ultimate goal is to learn to deny the world and thus achieve release or moksha.
·         Vishnu--had many avatars or appearances as a fish, tortoise, dwarf, Rama, Krishna, and Buddha. The last one is yet to come. Kalkin--a warrior, will appear on a white steed with flaming sword, will judge the evil ones, reward the righteous and set up an ideal world.
·         Personal Salvation--can be obtained through a number of ways:
o   Jnana- -knowledge( ascet icism,m edi tat ion)
o   Karma--deeds (obedience to caste rules)
o   Bhakti--devotion (worship of the gods)
  • Four Goals:
o   Dharma (specified duties of one's caste)
o   Artha (worldly concern--how to get along with the world legitimately)
o   Kama (pursuit of love and pleasure)
o   Moksha (release)
  • Ideal life cycle of man in Hinduism (from the Code of Manu) as a man grows older. Student, Householder, Hermit,  Wandering beggar
  • The Cow is sacred because it exemplifies non-aggression and non-materialism.
  • There is seemingly no purpose to this life except man seeks to be released from the endless cycle of death and rebirth and to be united with the spirit of the universe through work
  •  Salvation from the cycle of death and rebirth is through works. Works can be rituals, good deeds, meditation, or devotion to God.
Two Essays

This documentary shows an ancient, sacred Apache ritual that has never before been
filmed. The Sunrise Ceremony(Markstrom & Iborra, 2003), which marks the passage from
adolescence to adulthood for young Apache women, is disappearing under the pressures of
cultural assimilation. This documentary focuses on the Sunrise Ceremony of 13-year-old
Maureen Nachu, who lives on the Fort Apache Reservation in Whiteriver, Arizona, and is a
member of the White Mountain Apache Tribe.
The Sunrise Dance itself is a tremendous physical test, lasting four days. It proves that
Maureen has the courage and strength of character to take her place in adult society. The dance is
the strongest commitment a young Apache girl can make to her family and tradition. For
Maureen, her family and her community, the ceremony is a reaffirmation of tribal identity and a
celebration of the central role of women in Apache culture. Almost every Western Apache girl
had a puberty ceremony, or na'ii'ees ('preparing her,' or 'getting her ready')(Gaines, 2000), known
popularly as the Sunrise Dance. Today, this is no longer true. Although puberty ceremonies
continue to be performed on a regular basis, most Apache girls now must do without them. Two
reasons for this decline are apparent. First, as a result of inroads made on the traditional religion
by missionaries, some Apaches no longer believe in the effectiveness of na'ii'ees. A second
reason that na'ii'ees is held less and less is its prohibitive cost. The amount of money and work
required is staggering and this condition makes the ceremony impossible for many people.
Na'ii'ees is a ritual enactment of the Apache origin myth. Long ago, according to the
myths(Potter-Basso, 1991), Is dzán naadleeshe', Changing Woman lived all alone. One day she
had sexual intercourse with the Sun, and as a result of this union brought forth Naye' nazgháné-
(Slayer of Monsters), the foremost Western Apache culture
hero.http://www.grrlstories.org/rites/ROPApache.htm  four days later, Changing
Woman became pregnant by Water Old-Man and gave birth to Túbaadeschine (Born of Water
Old-Man). As the twins matured, Changing Woman and other powerful figures taught them all
of the things Apaches needed to know. As soon as they were old enough, Naye' nazgháné-and;
Túbaadeschine left home and rid the earth of much evil.
Changing Woman's power grants longevity. Although she grows old, she is always able
to recapture her youth by walking towards the east and turning around counterclockwise four
times. This power is transferred to the pubescent girl through songs sung by the diiyin ('one who
has power'), the medicine man. The thirty-two or more songs are believed to have first been sung
by Changing Woman and are collectively known as gohzhoosih ('songs of beauty and
goodness'). This power resides in her for four days after the ceremony. During this period, the
pubescent girl personifies Changing Woman and is said to be able to cure the sick and bring rain.

Sunrise Dance




The Art of the Dogonhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=epqg5EiX6tw

 

The Dogon people of Mali possess one of the richest art traditions in West Africa. Residing in an imposing landscape of steep cliffs and arid plains, the Dogon have for centuries created powerful sculpture to use in various rituals and in their daily life.
 One of the great admirers and collectors of Dogon art is Lester Wunderman. This half-hour film is based on his extensive collection at the Metropolitan Museum and his archival footage which was shot on location in Mali. The Art of the Dogon attempts to capture the beauty and power of Dogon at while placing it in context within Dogon beliefs and culture.
The video shows Dogon art in two radically different contexts. There are clips of an exhibition in Texas dedicated to their art, and then the video attempts to place the objects in the context of their actual use in Dogon society. An issue we need to keep in mind does not just understand the social context of the production of the work of art, but how it is consumed or experienced in the different cultural contexts. On the basis of this contrast articulate the different roles of art in Dogon society and the modern museum.
At various points in the video connections are made to art in the western world: comparisons are made between African tribal traditions and Primitivism in Modern art. To understand this phenomenon, we must begin by focusing our attention, not on the art objects themselves, nor on the people who made them, but rather on those who have defined, developed, and defended, and defended the internationalization of Primitive Art, and other racial, cultural, political, and economic visions.

Understanding that Dogon society is a non-literate society while without writing, art objects can acquire extraordinary importance as visual records. On a simple level, the possession of a particular object --a crown, for example-- can prove the legitimacy of succession. The right to sacrifice to a particular ancestor can carry with it the inherited right to farm certain land. On a deeper level, works of art are endowed with complex meaning and serve as repositories of traditional knowledge.

No comments:

Post a Comment